The three strippers at the centre of the Sydney Swans hotel incident are pinning their last hopes on a swift financial settlement, the Daily Mail understands.
While the AFL players linked to the scandal have always maintained their innocence and were cleared by police last week, the women believe it could be a different matter for the club, which has gone from one PR disaster to another in recent months.
Sources say the trio of dancers suspect the controversy-averse team may settle to avoid the Pullman matter being litigated in a civil court.
The Mail does not suggest the players themselves would be open to any kind of settlement to make the matter go away, given they have always denied the claims, only that the women are hoping for some kind of settlement with the Swans.
Central to their belief that they still have the upper hand is that the Swans would supposedly do anything to avoid having allegations aired publicly in civil proceedings.
Each of the women retained civil lawyers within days of the party at the Pullman East Melbourne hotel on August 17, paving the way for a potential financial resolution.
The three strippers at the centre of the Sydney Swans hotel incident are pinning their last hopes on a swift financial settlement, the Daily Mail understands. (James Jordon, Isaac Heeney and Nick Blakey are seen arriving for their end-of-season meetings in September)
Sources say the trio of dancers suspect the controversy-averse team may settle to avoid the Pullman matter being litigated in a civil court. (Stock image posed by model)
The adult entertainers had been hired to perform lap dances at a private party at the Pullman hotel (pictured) following the club’s victory over Essendon on August 16, and later claimed they were all sexually assaulted. Victoria Police confirmed on Friday that no charges would be laid
Previous Australian cases involving unwanted sexual touching – which is what the Mail understands is the central allegation in the matter – have resulted in awards of about $20,000, but a confidential settlement involving a non-disclosure agreement could potentially command a larger sum.
The Mail does not suggest any of the players engaged in the conduct alleged by the women and acknowledges that police found insufficient evidence to lay criminal charges. We simply note that the women’s lawyers intend to pursue civil proceedings and that separate matters involving similar allegations have, in some cases, resulted in financial settlements. Nor does the Mail suggest the women or their lawyers are pursuing a meritless claim in the hope of extracting a payout from a publicity-shy club, only that they are aware of the Swans’ desire to put the controversy behind them before next season and believe that may strengthen their negotiating position.
Meanwhile, friends of one of the women told the Mail the three are living in a state of paranoia, fearful that Swans fans could seek revenge against them for speaking out.
‘They’re constantly looking over their shoulders, worried that someone might recognise them and decide to take matters into their own hands,’ one friend said.
‘These players have incredibly loyal fans and the girls are terrified someone might want to punish them for what they’ve said.
‘They genuinely fear for their safety and want this to be over with as soon as possible.
‘But they don’t want to drop it because they feel they are owed compensation [from the club] for what happened and also believe that the psychological damage of the fallout since means they can never really work again in the industry.’
The adult entertainers had been hired to perform lap dances at a private party following the club’s victory over Essendon on August 16, and later claimed they were all sexually assaulted.
Swans stars Isaac Heeney (pictured with his ex-fiancée Steffie Waters), James Jordon, Nick Blakey, Chad Warner and Riley Bice were all stood down for the remainder of the season for breaching the team’s code of conduct by attending the late-night party
Respected lawyer John Karantzis (pictured), of Carbone Lawyers, who represents two of the women, said that his clients were ‘very disappointed and distressed’ by the police decision
Swans stars Isaac Heeney, James Jordon, Nick Blakey, Chad Warner and Riley Bice were all stood down for the remainder of the season for breaching the team’s code of conduct – a club decision that was separate to any police investigation.
Bice was later downgraded to a witness and the other men were cleared last week.
According to our source, some of the men were ‘wasted’ at the gathering, swaying and unsteady on their feet as the women shimmied through their routines.
At one stage, a woman said that if the players wanted to touch the dancers, they would have to pay more.
‘One guy agreed to pay an extra $50 to slap her a**e three times,’ said the source.
‘Another player was barefoot and seemed to want to touch them with his feet.’ The Mail does not suggest this was improper or non-consensual.
The Mail understands the allegations centred on touching without consent, a woman’s hands being placed on top of a man’s groin area, and another woman claiming that she was ‘dry humped’.
One of the three also alleged she suffered a medical episode during a lap dance and stepped out of the hotel room to get some air. There is no suggestion the players caused her to feel unwell.
She claimed the footballers asked her to cover up before she left, leaving her feeling as though they were more concerned about being seen with a topless woman than about her welfare.
Under Australian law, bystanders generally have no legal duty to come to someone’s aid, although a duty of care can arise depending on their role and the circumstances.
On November 3, lawyers acting for two of the three women sent letters of demand and a draft statement of claim.
One of the letters, sent to the club, argued that it was responsible for part of the alleged behaviour as the players’ employer.
Hours after police announced the criminal investigation had concluded, lawyers representing all three women confirmed they would press ahead with civil action.
Jackson Pannam, of Slater and Gordon, said his client was ‘devastated’ by the decision not to lay charges.
‘She reported the incident immediately, provided a formal statement and cooperated fully with the investigation,’ he said.
‘She has shown enormous courage in coming forward.’
A view of the Party Girls Melbourne website. The strippers were hired from the agency
Pannam stressed that the absence of criminal charges did not prevent his client from pursuing compensation through the civil courts, where claims are decided on the balance of probabilities rather than the higher criminal standard of proof.
John Karantzis, of Carbone Lawyers, who represents the other two women, remarked that his clients were ‘very disappointed and distressed’ by the police decision.
‘We will vigorously pursue this claim,’ he said.
The looming legal fight presents another headache for the Sydney Swans, who are already under fire over the club’s culture following a string of off-field controversies.
The latest incident saw star forward Tom Papley return a preliminary positive roadside drug test, while also being issued a court attendance notice for driving with a suspended licence.
The club has since commissioned an independent review of its AFL program, with chief executive Matthew Pavlich admitting the Swans had let supporters down and needed to do better.
