Labour’s own adviser blamed Government policies for fuelling the youth joblessness crisis today.
Alan Milburn said there was ‘no doubt’ that policies such as hiking national insurance and the minumum wage had hit business sentiment.
The bruising comments came as the former minister briefed Cabinet on his landmark report into NEETs – young people not in education, employment or training.
His proposals for tackling the eye-watering levels of inactivity among those aged 16-24 were released this morning. They include huge immediate investment in work support on the one hand, but also stripping youngsters who do not cooperate of welfare.
The Government is set to endorse most of the proposals – while likely rejecting the idea of cutting NICs for firms employing young people.
However, it has emerged that legislation on implementing any changes is not likely until the middle of next year. That added to fevered speculation at Westminster about Andy Burnham calling a May election, as Labour MPs are already threatening a highly damaging revolt against any effort to cut benefits.
On a tour of broadcast studios, Mr Milburn said: ‘Well, there’s no doubt that that has hit business sentiment. Absolutely, no doubt at all… Employers have come to me and said that that has made it harder.’
The ex-MP is urging the Government to make it ‘cheaper, simpler and less risky to hire a young person’.
Recommendations include reversing part of Rachel Reeves‘ £25billion raid on employers’ National Insurance (NI) contributions, slowing the rate of increase in the youth minimum wage and pausing elements of Angela Rayner‘s Employment Rights Act.
Mr Milburn will also call for a new law to force ministers to consider the impacts of potential tax hikes and regulations on the prospects of young workers before they are implemented.
Alan Milburn briefed Cabinet this morning on his landmark report into NEETs – young people not in education, employment or training
Angela Rayner was at the weekly gathering of ministers in Downing Street today
Ministers arrived for the weekly Cabinet this morning
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood arriving for Cabinet today
He proposed spending billions of pounds on new job schemes and subsidies, to help tackle a situation that has seen more than a million young people classified as Neets – not in education, employment or training.
But he warned that reforming welfare ‘the Labour way’ will cost billions and will not deliver savings for at least ten years.
Labour MPs have already been laying the ground for a revolt against any cuts to payments, after Keir Starmer‘s premiership was effectively killed off by a previous rebellion.
It is understood that Government policy based on Mr Milburn’s review is expected to be published in the New Year. Legislation would then follow in the ‘middle’ of next year.
Key votes might not happen for some time after that. If Mr Burnham wanted to call a national poll for May he would need to dissolve Parliament by the end of March.
Mr Milburn today defended his idea of stripping benefits from young people who reject a ‘legal guarantee’ of work, training or employment support.
‘I think, honestly, if you can work a few hours a week rather than working none and doomscrolling in your bedroom, that’s a step forward,’ he said.
‘In the end, for the vast majority of young people, work beats welfare every single time.’
The review warns that without ‘radical reforms’, as many as 1.27million under-25s will be classed as Neet – not in employment, education or training – in five years’ time.
It proposes everything from a new benefits system that will leave some worse off to a one-stop-shop for support, state subsidies for jobs, cuts to Rachel Reeves’ National Insurance hikes, extra school tests and a ‘digital front door’ for immediate access to NHS mental health services.
But although its goal is to reach ‘Neet Zero’, the proposed measures are only expected to reduced the Neet rate from 13 per cent currently – equivalent to 981,000 people aged 16 to 24 across the UK – to 6.8 per cent in 2036.
And the report admits the programme will only start to make savings in a decade’s time, when £5.8bn in annual funding is expected to lead to a £6bn reduction in welfare spending.
Despite the long-term nature of his plans, Mr Milburn urges ministers to start work on implementing them immediately – demanding a timetable for the cash within 100 days and a £500m downpayment next year.
His 278-page report concludes: ‘There is no honest version of change in which the country declares youth participation a national priority and then refuses to pay for making it real. We have to put our money where our mouth is.’
And it warns: ‘The alternative is not cost free. Lower employment, weaker growth, bigger benefit bills, poorer health and lost human potential all carry a price. The choice is whether we invest earlier in participation or continue paying later for failure.’
Kemi Badenoch welcomed the focus on youth jobs but urged Labour to ‘stop doing the stupid things’ that have contributed to the Neets crisis.
The Tory leader said Labour ‘don’t want to cut welfare’ and questioned whether the review would ever save the taxpayer money.
She added: ‘They have made hiring young people virtually impossible with the jobs tax, the equivalence on the youth minimum wage, the Employment Rights Act – they have made it really tough.
‘Now they are talking about paying businesses to try to bring those young people into employment. How about just stop doing the stupid things in the first place?’
Mr Milburn’s report is central to Mr Burnham’s claim that he can reduce the runaway benefits bill ‘in a Labour way’ without resorting to ‘crude cuts’.
Join the discussion
How should Britain fix its youth unemployment crisis without hurting businesses or young workers?
Milburn wants a ‘young people’s guarantee’ to be brought in, entitling under-25s to a training place or work
The study says that Britain has ended up with nearly 1m Neets thanks to ‘failure’ by the state and the market, and that young people – already hit by social media, Covid and mental distress – face a ‘future of uncertainty’ as Artificial Intelligence upends the world of work.
A survey carried out for the review found that one in three Neets had never been in paid work, and 48 per cent said they had a long-term health condition.
The report says a major driver in the crisis is the ‘first rung on the career ladder’ becoming harder for young people to reach, with youth employment rates falling by 4.3 percentage points – equivalent to 330,000 people – between December 2022 and the end of last year.
Entry level vacancies have fallen by 49 per cent over the past decade with young people without experience on their CVs or family contacts finding it hardest to get job offers.
Yet the review is also scathing about the cumulative impact of Labour’s policies including increases to the minimum wage, National Insurance hikes for employers and new protections under the Employment Rights Act.
‘Over recent years the cost and complexity of hiring young workers has increased sharply,’ it says.
‘Government has a legitimate role in safeguarding workers and consumers and in acting where markets fail. But when it uses tax, regulation and law, it must ask whether it is helping or hindering employers in creating more opportunities for young people.’
Wage costs for young people aged between 18 and 20 have soared by 65 per cent over the past five years while the NI rate has increased and the threshold fallen, adding £800 to the cost of a full-time worker.
‘There is nothing progressive about pricing young people out of work,’ the review states.
Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden will welcome the proposals but is expected to stop short of accepting them in full.
As Chancellor, Ms Reeves raised the headline rate of the tax, but also slashed the earnings threshold at which it is paid from £9,100 to just £5,000, dragging huge numbers of part-time starter jobs into the system.
Mr Milburn will say the threshold should be raised to £10,000 over time. He will warn that Labour’s bid to equalise the minimum wage paid to young people with the main rate has damaged job prospects, citing evidence that wage costs for young workers have jumped by 65 per cent in five years.
He will take aim at the Employment Rights Act, championed by then-deputy prime minister Angela Rayner, saying that a plan to end zero-hour contracts risks shutting more young people out of the workplace.
Despite Mr Burnham’s flat denials, election speculation has been intensifying in Westminster as Labour’s poll bounce from switching leaders sustains.
Rumours were fuelled by John Healey pushing back key decisions in the Budget at the end of last month.
A spending review due in the second half of next year will need to spell out a path for defence budgets hitting 3 per cent of GDP by 2030.
Mr Healey has also acknowledged there will have to be difficult choices on departmental spending, with think-tanks flagging that current plans seem to entail huge real-terms cuts in the coming years.
Mr Burnham also suggested in his Mansion House speech last night that decisions on Labour’s stance on rejoining the EU might be taken after the next election.
One Labour MP told the Daily Mail: ‘Everything points to him calling it in May. All the difficult decisions have been kicked back to the back half of 2027.
‘The spending review is going to be a nightmare.’
The former minister added: ‘Andy and James Purnell were both around when Gordon Brown failed to call the election in 2007, they are scarred by it.
‘They will be desperate not to make that mistake again.’
A poll today suggested Labour is maintaining a lead over the Tories and Reform
Kemi Badenoch urged Labour to ‘stop doing the stupid things’ that have contributed to the Neets crisis
Reform UK’s education spokesman, Suella Braverman, described the findings as a ‘glaring admission that Labour’s jobs tax has failed’.
She added: ‘It destroyed opportunities for workers, and particularly youngsters. Huge amounts of damage could have been avoided if Labour listened to the warnings.
‘Waiting ten years to fix the youth jobs crisis is a missed opportunity. We would be consigning another generation to the scrap heap.’
The Tories have proposed slashing £36.1billion from the welfare bill, coupled with a plan to cut the NI hike in half for young people.
Mr Milburn’s report will warn that savings from reforms will follow only after many years.
Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said: ‘Milburn is right to criticise the tax and regulation burdens Labour have imposed on businesses. But his review is too cautious. It fails to bring down the welfare bill… and won’t make the slightest difference for young people stuck on welfare now.’
