A North Carolina pub threatened to add a 20 percent automatic gratuity fee on customers who did not tip ‘well,’ prompting online commenters to sound off on the establishment’s surprising tactic.
Internet users slammed Freeman’s Grub & Pub in Greensboro after a Reddit user uploaded a picture of a sign found at the restaurant.
‘If our employees have 2 separate instances of you not tipping well without any explanation, we will add a 20% autograt fee on your bill,’ the sign read.
The sign added that ‘on average, the tip percentage in the US is 20% or above anytime you are provided service.’
Users were quick to push back, with one writing: ‘If this is real, I hope this place goes out of business because forcing customers to tip is just out of control.’
‘I wonder at what point does this kind of thing becomes theft/extortion?’ another Reddit user asked.
However, others defended the pub with one user saying that ‘tips were never optional’ and adding, ‘Its [sic] amazing how committed you guys are to being obtuse and anti social.’
Kevin Purcell, who owns the restaurant with his wife Emily, called the online commenters ‘a bunch of lonely Karens’ in a video on Monday morning and added, ‘Please know that we are talking s*** about how pathetic it is that you’re dogpiling on subreddit over a sign in a restaurant you were never coming to anyway.’
Freeman’s Grub & Pub in Greensboro, North Carolina, is facing criticism after a sign detailing their automatic gratuity fee began circulating on Reddit
The sign at the center of the controversy warned patrons with two separate instances of ‘not tipping well’ that they would be slapped with a 20 percent automatic gratuity fee
The restaurant added that customers’ receipts would be saved and that they were ‘welcome to question’ the automatically-added fee.
‘But ultimately our employees have served you and if there were no issues, there shouldn’t be a low tip,’ the pub added.
The user who uploaded the sign said he was taken to the pub by a family member and that it would be his ‘first and last time’ going there.
However, he did not say whether he left a tip or not.
Other commenters agreed with him, with one adding that the sign exemplified why they did not usually venture out to eat.
‘If you don’t want people patronizing your business, put up a sign like this,’ another Reddit user wrote.
A third user said they would simply refuse to tip the restaurant, saying the automatic fee was a step too far.
‘When you cross the line from a gratuity given for excellent service to an automatic 20% charge because you exist, not only are you not getting the 20%, you’re not going to get the opportunity to collect from me as a customer whatsoever,’ he wrote.
‘So add your 20% automatic payment to zero,’ the user continued. ‘What do you get?’
Kevin Purcell, an owner of the establishment, said that online users criticizing the policy could ‘kick f***ing rocks’
Another commenter called the restaurant’s tactics ’embarrassing’ and said they were surprised that the sign had even been placed.
Other users were more ironic in their descriptions of the restaurant’s announced fee.
‘You must pay our employees because we don’t,’ one Reddit commenter wrote.
‘Absolute bulls***,’ a second user commented. ‘Just another business owner using tips as an excuse to underpay their employees.’
‘I will NOT pay your employees salary,’ a third user said. ‘That is your job.’
Still, others were more acquiescent of the restaurant and even showed signs of support for the policy, with one user calling it a ‘win-win.’
‘It is a turn off to the people who don’t tip, and they don’t want those customers,’ the user wrote. ‘You don’t want to eat there, and they don’t want you to eat there.’
A separate user insisted that the restaurant simply did not ‘want non-tippers’ and predicted that ‘they will be okay.’
‘Hell yea,’ a third user posted. ‘Good on them.’
Purcell said Freeman’s Grub & Pub had also been hit with nasty reviews online in wake of the controversy over the tipping sign
Purcell, the owner of the restaurant, said that he was not going to comment on the criticism by addressing the ‘troubled history of tipping’ in the US, but emphasized that ‘it is 2026’ in the video he posted Monday.
‘You should know by now the rules of engagement, expectations to tip at a bar or restaurant,’ Purcell said.
He said the tip money would go to the restaurant’s staff so they could ‘feed their kids … take care of their families [and] try to survive in this economy just like everybody else.’
Purcell also suggested that corporate servers were ‘encouraged to grin and bear it and pass the buck with free appetizer coupons’ as he spoke on the backlash.
‘Here at our mom and pop joint, you can kick f***ing rocks, so we’ll stand behind our controversial policy and our amazing staff 100 percent,’ he said.
Purcell added that the criticism had intensified to the point where people were leaving negative reviews for the restaurant online.
The Daily Mail has reached out to Freeman’s Grub & Pub in Greensboro for further comment.
