Cricket Australia’s decision to set up an ‘independent forum’ to allow their cricketers a ‘safe setting’ in which to talk openly about the sandpaper fiasco looks at first sight like a decent idea. But, for a few reasons, it is likely to end in failure. It may even make things worse.
In an impromptu press conference held, incongruously, by a children’s playground outside Hobart’s Ninja Stadium, Todd Greenberg and David Boon – CA’s chief executive and chair – tried to make the best of a bad job after a week in which conflicting accounts of what happened in South Africa eight years ago have thrown Australian cricket into disarray.
Some of that bad job is not their fault. Had their predecessors on the board made a better fist of the original investigation in 2018 – hurried through in 48 hours, and conveniently settling on three scapegoats – we might not be here now.
But from the moment the vacuum was filled so damningly by Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, the folly of CA’s initial sloppiness has been exposed. And it’s unclear how a forum is going to compensate.
Boon, a gnarled veteran of 107 Tests who looked pained to be having to mediate in this sporting civil war, said it was time for a ‘circuit breaker’.
Greenberg added: ‘The game is genuinely hurting at the moment. It’s not good for anyone. We need to find a path through, and we need some time to heal.’
He said the forum was ‘a chance to give everyone a voice in an independent and a safe setting. It’s not a re-investigation. It’s not designed to re-prosecute or to sanction. No one is compelled to participate.’
Cricket Australia’s interim chairman David Boon (right) and CEO Todd Greenberg gave an impromptu press conference by a children’s playground in Hobart
The pair were speaking before the third ODI between Australia and England
To which the reasonable response might be: what, in that case, is the point? If a forum simply amplifies the different versions of what happened at Port Elizabeth and Cape Town, how will that help Australian cricket ‘move forward together’, as Boon put it?
That strange sound you can hear? It’s the can of VB being kicked down the road.
It was hard to avoid the thought that CA, whose board met late into the night on Tuesday to discuss their response, were driven by the need not just to regain some kind of control of the narrative, but by the desire to spike the guns of more potential testimony.
There have been whispers that Cameron Bancroft, whose career never recovered from his part in the scam, was preparing to go public, while Steve Smith recently arrived in Australia from his home in New York ahead of New South Wales’s Sheffield Shield match against Queensland at Sydney on Sunday. He is not expected to speak, but that won’t stop journalists from trying.
Even if they do reveal their hand, Greenberg’s comments suggest that no single version of the truth can ever be established.
Bizarrely, he claimed that the diametrically opposed accounts provided by Pat Cummins in Sydney on Friday and Chadd Sayers – 12th man in South Africa – in Adelaide on Sunday, could ‘both be true because it’s their version of events’.
Sounding unnervingly like Donald Trump, he went on: ‘Their version of events is their truth. I’m not here to tell someone what they believe, nor should they tell me what I believe. My version of events might be different to yours. They can be true to you, and they can be true to me. That’s the complete difficulty in this challenge.’
By definition, then, Cummins won’t be accused by CA of lying when he described Khawaja’s claim that the whole team knew about the sandpaper plot as ‘complete and utter nonsense’.
There is a further issue, practical rather than philosophical. Greenberg insisted the process, which he hopes will take no longer than a month, and be presided over by a KC or a judge, will be confidential. At the same time, he said the board would also decide what would be made public.
Steve Smith, punished for this part in sandpapergate, will not be forced to contribute to the forum
Usman Khawaja (left) and David Warner, reacting before the third ODI, were quick to express their scepticism over the forum
It is a halfway house with serious repercussions: if the players are unsure which parts of their testimony will end up in the public domain, will they speak openly?
And it was a problem immediately identified by Khawaja, who followed proceedings from inside the ground ahead of his punditry stint on the third one-day international between Australia and England.
‘I respect what Greenberg is trying to do there,’ he said. ‘But at the end of the day, if you’re going to cherry-pick what is said in this report, the board can choose whatever they want to come in or come out. Are we just going in a circle here?”
Also in attendance was Warner, who echoed his concern: ‘Where do we actually end here? Because it is upon the board to review what they want to be published.’
It is a valid point, and one to which CA have no compelling answer. In attempting to demonstrate leadership, and light the path towards resolution, they have only confirmed that more pain lies ahead.

