For employers grappling with the rise of artificial intelligence, the challenge is no longer whether staff are using the technology, but how.
Recent Australian court and Fair Work Commission decisions reveal workers have already lost jobs, damaged careers and found themselves at the centre of legal disputes after relying on AI-generated content for everything from legal research to workplace correspondence.
In one of Australia’s most embarrassing AI legal blunders, a South Australian solicitor told the Federal Circuit and Family Court she had terminated her paralegal after AI was used to prepare documents for a family law appeal that contained what the court described as ‘non-existent, inaccurate and misleading authorities’.
The court found the filing included AI ‘hallucinations’ in the form of ‘inaccurate and misleading references to case law’ that had not been checked before being submitted.
It ultimately found the use of AI had resulted in ‘erroneous citations’ and referred the lawyers involved to their respective legal regulators.
Another case involved Marcus Wibmer, whose downfall at Fujifilm Data Management Solutions began after he took offence to a colleague’s Microsoft Teams message, triggering a months-long workplace dispute marked by escalating complaints and increasingly combative AI-assisted emails.
Fair Work Deputy President Tony Slevin said Mr Wibmer’s reliance on artificial intelligence was ‘unfortunate’ and ‘counterproductive’, and ultimately ‘led to his demise’.
‘The communications it produced were dense, repetitive and often rambling,’ he said.
Employment law expert Mia Pantechis (pictured) said the cases were likely to be the first of many and predicted AI policies would soon become as commonplace as social media policies
Research from Microsoft’s 2026 Work Trend Index suggests many workplaces are struggling to keep pace with the rapid uptake of AI
Courts and tribunals are increasingly dealing with the fallout of employees using AI
‘They were demanding and overbearing. They lacked context and perspective.
‘AI appears to have given Mr Wibmer a false sense of security that his communications, laden as they were with allegations of impropriety by his managers and demands for corrective action, were appropriate and acceptable in a workplace setting. They were not.’
Artificial intelligence provided by AI tools including ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot, is also being used in many disputes going through Fair Work.
In a 2026 bullying case, Commissioner McKinnon criticised correspondence that appeared to have been prepared using an AI tool, describing it as ‘lengthy, wide-ranging, replete with generalisations, repetitive, and often couched in accusatory language’.
While the commission ultimately found the worker had been bullied, it also observed that the AI-generated correspondence contributed to the breakdown in relations between the parties, underscoring growing scrutiny of how employees use artificial intelligence in workplace communications.
The emerging cases suggest employers, courts and workplace regulators are becoming less concerned with the use of AI itself and more focused on its consequences, particularly when workers rely on it to draft legal submissions, manage disputes or communicate with colleagues and managers.
In each case, the issue was not the use of AI itself, but the failure to properly check, verify or take responsibility for the material it produced.
Maurice Blackburn employment lawyer Mia Pantechis said the cases were likely to be the first of many and predicted AI policies would soon become as commonplace as social media policies.
Fair Work Deputy President Tony Slevin said said the reliance on artificial intelligence was ‘unfortunate’ and ‘counterproductive’ in the case of one sacked employee
‘This isn’t a new type of misconduct. It’s an old one with a new tool,’ she told the Daily Mail.
‘Workers have always been accountable for what they put their name to. AI just makes it faster and easier to get it wrong, and at scale.
‘We’ll see more of these cases, not because workers are careless, but because employers have handed them powerful tools, and often without clear rules, training and guardrails.’
Ms Pantechis said responsibility did not end with workers alone.
‘Employers who roll out AI, or expect staff to use it to work faster, without clear policies or training, can’t then act shocked when things go wrong. Accountability has to run both ways.’
She said the early disputes could prove to be a turning point in how workplaces manage the risks posed by artificial intelligence.
‘These early cases will be remembered as the moment workplaces were forced to work out who carries the risk when AI gets it wrong. Workers shouldn’t be left carrying all of the risk.’
Ms Pantechis said AI could provide workers with false confidence during workplace conflicts.
Centre for Future Work policy director Fiona Macdonald (pictured) said workplaces were still scrambling to establish rules around artificial intelligence
‘When employees are stressed and in conflict at work, AI can be the perfect ‘yes man’ and provide a false sense of security about the communications being sent and threatened legal claims.
‘AI might sharpen your grievance, but it won’t tell you to sleep on it, and it won’t be the one who gets sacked if the communications or behaviours are unjustified.’
Research from Microsoft’s 2026 Work Trend Index suggests many workplaces are struggling to keep pace with the rapid uptake of AI.
Just 26 per cent of AI users said their leadership was clearly and consistently aligned on AI, with the report finding employees were often moving faster than their employers when it came to adopting the technology.
Centre for Future Work policy director Fiona Macdonald said workplaces were still scrambling to establish rules around artificial intelligence.
‘The use of AI is speeding past any governance or systems that we have in place on how we use it and when we can use it,’ she told the Daily Mail.
‘A lot of workplaces don’t [have guidance], and they’re racing to catch up, racing to understand what they need to have, while employees are potentially thinking they’re doing the right thing and steaming ahead.’
Ms Pantechis said if you hit send, you own it.
‘You can’t blame the software,’ she said.
‘Never send anything you haven’t read, understood, and would be happy to defend in a disciplinary meeting. And if you’re in a dispute with your employer, talk to your union or a lawyer, not a chatbot.’
