A Christian pastor who was arrested for allegedly criticising Islam while preaching on a high street has revealed his relief after police closed his case with no further action.
Steve Maile, 67, had been speaking to the public in Watford about his thoughts on violence within Islam when discussing whether the faith was a religion of peace.
The Oasis City Church pastor, who is a married father-of-four and grandfather, was also singing Christian hymns and songs in the busy shopping area on April 18.
Mr Maile, who was preaching and singing for about ten minutes, is also said to have told onlookers that he had compassion and wanted Muslims to become Christians.
But three Hertfordshire Police officers then put Mr Maile in handcuffs and arrested him on suspicion of assault and racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour – with one of them filmed shouting at him: ‘In the name of Jesus, get in the car.’
Seven months later, the force has confirmed to Mr Maile that it will take no further action because the evidence available did not meet the threshold to charge him.
Mr Maile, who could now bring a civil claim against the police over his arrest and treatment in custody, said: ‘I am relieved that the police have finally confirmed what I knew from the beginning: I had committed no crime.
‘I was peacefully preaching the gospel, singing and speaking about my Christian beliefs. Criticising Islam is not a criminal offence. This ordeal has taken a terrible toll on me and my family.
Three Hertfordshire Police officers put Steve Maile in handcuffs in Watford and arrest him
The arrest is on suspicion of assault and racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour
‘Being suddenly surrounded by police officers, handcuffed in front of my family and taken away as if I were a dangerous criminal was humiliating and deeply distressing.’
Mr Maile claimed he was handcuffed tightly by police for around an hour and a half, including with a so‑called ‘double lock’, despite telling officers he was in pain. He later required medical attention and splints for injuries to his hands.
He said: ‘The handcuffs caused me severe pain and injuries to my hands, for which I needed medical treatment and splints. But the emotional impact has lasted much longer.
‘I have experienced sleepless nights and exhaustion, and my family has had to live for months with the anxiety of not knowing whether I would be prosecuted simply for preaching my faith.
‘My loved ones have watched me suffer physically and emotionally. They should never have been put through that. An arrest does not affect only the person in handcuffs; it affects their spouse, their children, their grandchildren and everyone close to them.
‘There is relief today, but there is also righteous anger. This case ending with no further action does not erase what happened.’
Mr Maile insisted that he wanted an apology and ‘will not be silenced or intimidated’, adding: ‘I will continue to preach the gospel publicly, including in Watford, and I will continue to tell people about the love and saving power of Jesus Christ.’
He concluded: ‘I have preached for 45 years because I love people and want them to know Jesus. I do not attack individuals and I do not call for hatred or violence. I plead with people to come to Christ.
‘The police picked on the wrong man if they thought this arrest would frighten me into silence. I forgive those involved, but forgiveness does not mean there should be no accountability. I will continue to stand for truth, freedom and the gospel.’
An officer shouts at Mr Maile as he is put in the police car: ‘In the name of Jesus, get in the car’
Mr Maile asks the officer to remove his handcuffs because is in pain, but she closes the door
Video of his arrest in April showed a visibly furious Mr Maile shouting: ‘I am a preacher of the Gospel. Watch this. There is no offence being committed here, none whatsoever.’
As one of the officers repeatedly encouraged Mr Maile to stop talking so they could ‘explain the grounds’ for his arrest, he told them: ‘You repent and believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and you’ll be saved. This is an utter disgrace, in this nation.’
Mr Maile was then accused of assaulting a child, to which he replied: ‘I’ve not assaulted anyone, no, no, no. Take these off now, in the name of Jesus. You people should be ashamed of yourselves, arresting a minister of the gospel in Watford.’
A woman filming the arrest also defended him, saying: ‘Which child? I’ve been filming every moment and he has not assaulted a child. This is a grandfather, he is a pastor.’
Boos could be heard as Mr Maile was put into the car, and he shouted: ‘Mums and dads, boys and girls, watch this – this is the police in our country. Get your filthy hand off my head now. Get your hand off my head now. In the name of Jesus.’
A woman officer then shouted at him: ‘In the name of Jesus, get in the car.’
Before closing the car door, Mr Maile also shouted: ‘My wrists have been hurt, will you please take these off? These are hurting me. This is assault.’
As the onlooker insisted he had not assaulted a child, another officer said: ‘Okay, well we’ve had conflicting reports and we’ve had witnesses tell us as well, so we need to look into it, so we’re dealing with it. We can’t tell you anymore because he’s an adult.’
Mr Maile has preached in more than 50 countries. He has no previous criminal record and is also a singer who has released five albums.
He was first taken to Watford police station before being transferred to Hatfield police station, and claims he was held for a total of up to 12 hours.
Steve Maile founded the non-denominational Oasis City Church in 1999 with his wife Karina
Mr Maile also claimed to have been denied access to a toilet for a prolonged period and said that his family were not informed where he had been taken.
He was initially accused of assaulting a teenager, but he strongly denied the allegation and it was later dropped.
However, Mr Maile had remained under investigation for a Section 5 public order offence, relating to racially or religiously aggravated disorderly behaviour.
He believed this was connected to comments he made which were critical of Islam as well as homosexuality, but maintained these were Bible-based statements.
Mr Maile, who became a Christian in 1979, founded the non-denominational Oasis City Church in 1999 with his wife Karina, who is originally from Argentina.
He has been represented by lawyers at the Christian Legal Centre, which said it was concerned about the impact of the arrest on freedom of speech and religion.
The organisation’s chief executive Andrea Williams said: ‘Pastor Steve Maile has been completely vindicated, but he and his family should never have been forced to endure this ordeal.
‘It was sadly predictable that this case would end with no further action because the fundamental evidence of a crime was never there. Steve was peacefully preaching the Christian gospel and expressing criticism of Islam.
‘However uncomfortable some people may find his message, it is not a criminal offence to criticise a religion in public. In a free society, religions and ideologies must be open to scrutiny, debate and disagreement.
‘The police are not there to shield Islam, Christianity or any other belief system from criticism. Their duty is to uphold the law impartially and protect the fundamental freedoms on which our democracy depends.
‘Instead, a 66-year-old Christian pastor with no criminal record was surrounded by officers, painfully handcuffed, detained for hours and left under the shadow of a criminal investigation. Once again, the process became the punishment.’
Hertfordshire Constabulary has been contacted for comment by the Daily Mail.
In a letter sent to Mr Maile last month, the force said: ‘Based on the evidence currently available a decision has been made to refuse charge you [sic] in respect of the above offence(s) because the evidence did not meet evidential stage of the full code test set out in the Code for Crown Prosecutions.’
It added: ‘The case will be kept under review. The decision not to charge may be reconsidered if a review indicates that it was clearly wrong and should not be allowed to stand.’
