New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has been criticized for urging residents to sign up as snow shovelers, a position that requires two forms of identification.
Critics have pointed out that the request has come while Mamdani’s party, the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), has advocated against voter ID laws.
New York is bracing for its second major snowstorm this year, and Mamdani has asked for volunteers to help clear snow from the city’s streets for $19.14 per hour.
Mamdani said during a press conference that the city has prepared 33 vans and two buses with the Department of Sanitation to transport shovelers where they are needed.
‘Just show up at your local sanitation garage between 8am and 1pm tomorrow with your paperwork, which is accessible online at NYC.gov/now, and you can get started right away,’ the mayor said.
The online registration states that to be accepted for the position, applicants must be at least 18, eligible to work in the US, and able to perform heavy physical labor.
To register for an appointment, those interested must present two small photos of themselves, two original forms of ID, and a Social Security card.
The starting pay to shovel snow with the city is $19.14 per hour, increasing to $28.71 per hour after the first 40 hours worked in a week.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani was the subject of criticism online after he called for New Yorkers to sign up to be emergency snow shovelers when the position requires two forms of identification. Mamdani is pictured above at a press conference on the storm on Saturday
New York will soon be hit with another major snow storm. Pictured above are shovelers clearing out a subway station in Brooklyn
Emergency snow shovelers must be 18 years old, eligible to work in the US, and able to perform heavy physical labor
Social media users have argued that it does not make sense for New Yorkers to be required to provide identification to shovel snow, but not to vote at the polls.
‘This is why consistency in governance matters. Rules shouldn’t change depending on the political objective,’ one comment read.
‘I believe this to be taunting their hypocrisy on ID, it just has to be,’ another added.
‘To shovel now and trash but not to vote. [face palm emoji,’ a third agreed.
However, some argued that the two policies differ and cannot be compared, with one writing: ‘Criticize policy if needed, but comparing snow removal registration to voting laws is misleading.’
‘The comparison is more political than practical. ID checks for emergency work are usually about payment verification and worker safety, while voting laws are governed by separate legal standards,’ another pointed out.
The Daily Mail has reached out to the mayor’s office for comment.
It comes after Mamdani was criticized for letting heaps of trash and filthy snow clutter New York City streets, while the grounds of his $100 million mansion remained spotless.
Large piles of snow remained on the streets of the city more than three weeks after the last snow storm.
Mamdani said in a press conference that New Yorkers who want to earn some extra cash and help their neighbors can sign up to shovel snow. The position requires applicants to provide two small photos of themselves, two original forms of ID, and a Social Security card
Meanwhile, New Yorkers do not need to present identification at their polling stations. New York is one of many states that don’t require voters to bring ID to the polls.
However, you must be over 18, a US citizen, and a resident of New York to vote. To register in the state, prospective voters must provide their driver’s license number, state ID card number, or the last four digits of their Social Security number.
Prospective voters can leave that section blank if they do not have any of the above forms of identification, but if the state cannot confirm their identity, they must bring an accepted form of ID to their polling place.
Voter identification laws have become a hot topic in recent years, with progressives claiming they contribute to voter suppression, while conservatives argue it contributes to election fraud.
The DSA, a progressive political group to which Mamdani belongs, has previously spoken out against voter identification laws.
The party recently came out against the SAVE America Act, a Republican-backed bill that would require voters to provide a photo ID when casting their ballot.
‘Our candidates for office stand firm against racist voter ID laws and secret poll taxes like the “SAVE America Act,”‘ the DSA said in a statement.
