A heated debate has emerged over the future of Black Stars head coach Otto-Addo, with two prominent sports analysts offering sharply contrasting views on his suitability to lead Ghana at the 2026 FIFA World Cup.
Speaking on the Jupay World Cup Promo podcast last Friday, sports pundit coach Christopher Nimley called for the immediate dismissal of Addo, arguing that Ghana must prioritize quality and decisive leadership if it hopes to compete effectively on the global stage.
Nimley pointed to historical precedents to support his argument, referencing Ghana’s decision to replace Kwasi Appiah with Avram Grant shortly before the 2015 AFCON — a move that saw the Black Stars reach the final.
He also cited Algeria and Côte d’Ivoire as examples of nations that changed coaches close to or during tournaments and went on to win the Africa Cup of Nations.
He highlighted the need for the Black Stars to bring the best technical expertise to manage the World Cup campaign, especially because Ghana has set aside as much as USD13.67 million for this venture.
He argued that Otto-Addo has struggled to get the best out of Ghana’s squad, singling out Thomas Partey as the only player who consistently performs at a high level in the black stars. Nimley criticized what he described as poor in-game management and a lack of composure from the bench during crucial moments, insisting Ghana needs a calm and tactically assertive head coach. According to him, Ghana risks underperforming at the World Cup if it fails to address what he sees as leadership shortcomings.
However, sports journalist and pundit Fentuo Tahiru Fentuo proffered contrary assessment. While acknowledging his past reservations about Otto-Addo, he insisted that results so far cannot be ignored.
Fentuo admitted he was among critics who believed Otto-Addo should have been dismissed following Ghana’s failure to qualify for the Africa Cup of Nations.
However, he noted that once the Ghana Football Association retained him, Otto-Addo responded by successfully steering the team through the World Cup qualifiers.
“I’m not the biggest fan of Otto Addo. I though the failure to qualify for the AFCON was sacrilegious and he should have been fired right away but… when the FA made the decision to keep him, I was one of those who was up in arms and who thought it was not right – as if endorsing mediocrity and then he qualified the team for the World Cup.
“And let’s be honest here; it may not have been pretty the way we qualified, but we still qualified because at the end of the day, the most important this was the qualification and Otto -Addo excelled in qualification. In fact, since he took over the qualification, the eight matches that he played, he drew only one” he stated.
He added that while Otto’s performances were sometimes chaotic, they were ultimately results-oriented, and Addo appeared to have learned lessons from earlier setbacks.
“At the end of the day, if we played beautifully and failed to qualify, it wouldn’t bring satisfaction,” Fentuo said, stressing that pragmatism often defines successful tournament campaigns.
With expectations high and memories of past World Cup campaigns still fresh, the discussion over Otto Addo’s future appears far from settled.
Watch the full episode of the Jupay World Cup Promo below:
