Heading into this batch of games in the Nations Championship, much of the talk around Finn Russell had been about Bath’s patchy form in the early part of the new season.

Russell hadn’t been playing poorly. There were still flashes of brilliance at times, but the results were a mixed bag at best.

Of the six matches that Russell had started for Bath in the new season, they had won on only three occasions.

They suffered three consecutive defeats in October. Hefty defeats, too; 71-48 against Northampton, 23-5 against Gloucester, and a 32-14 loss to Montpellier in the Champions Cup.

Nobody would be naive enough to pin the blame entirely on Russell for those results, but his drop-off in form looked to be emblematic of Bath as a whole.

Certainly, he was not playing at the same level as he was in 2025 when he led Bath to the Premiership title before starring for the British and Irish Lions in their series win in Australia.

Finn Russell is tackled by Australia’s Len Ikitau at Murrayfield on Sunday

Russell has not been at his best in the autumn window of the Nations Championship

In an interview with Daily Mail Sport, former Scotland lock Jim Hamilton noted a couple of weeks ago: ‘I know Bath have struggled slightly at the start of the season. But it’s still Finn Russell — he’ll put on a Scotland jersey and he’ll be one of the best players in the world again.’

Yet, truthfully, it hasn’t quite panned out that way. Russell has gone off the boil with Scotland and hasn’t been at his best in the games against New Zealand and Australia over the past week.

Gregor Townsend was asked about the form of his fly-half following the defeat to the All Blacks at Murrayfield.

‘I actually think Finn has been fine for Bath over the first few weeks of the season,’ said the Scotland head coach. ‘But it wasn’t his best game against New Zealand. He will know that himself.

‘He will be disappointed and he will definitely want to put that right next week. He’s been very, very good for us over a long period. He will want to show that against Australia.’

But Russell wasn’t much better against the Wallabies on Sunday afternoon. Both with and without the ball, it was far from a vintage display.

He missed a vital tackle on Harry Potter early in the first half in the move which eventually saw the Australia winger score in the corner.

On punditry duties for BBC Radio Scotland, former Scotland prop Peter Wright said: ‘Finn Russell, that’s shocking.’

Russell’s kicking game wasn’t entirely on point in the narrow 15-12 win over Australia

Tackling is often a part of Russell’s game that goes unnoticed. He puts in a lot of big hits for a fly-half and rarely misses.

To see him falling off a tackle in such weak fashion was, indeed, surprising. But it wasn’t just that moment alone.

His kicking was loose and erratic. He was missing touch at times, whilst also kicking the ball straight back down Australia’s throats in other moments.

For the second week in succession, Scotland’s attack never really got going. By his own high standards, Russell looked subdued and ineffectual.

In the two matches against New Zealand and Australia, Scotland have scored five tries in total — and they have all come from the forwards. Ewan Ashman got a hat-trick against the All Blacks, with Jack Dempsey and Matt Fagerson then going over against the Wallabies.

The fact that none of the backs have scored at all over the two matches is emblematic of how Scotland’s attack just hasn’t fired.

There are times in Scottish rugby when any criticism of Russell is almost viewed as an act of blasphemy in some quarters. In the eyes of this observer, he is probably the nation’s greatest ever rugby player. But such lofty status should not make him immune to criticism.

Perhaps inevitably, he will be held to a higher standard than others in the Scotland team because we know the genius of which he is capable.

Speaking on a podcast last week, former South Africa captain Jean de Villiers claimed that Russell is currently ‘playing on reputation’.

On the back of one game against the All Blacks, that assessment felt slightly harsh. But given the lack of improvement against Australia, it becomes harder to argue.

Speaking on Sunday afternoon after a laboured and uninspiring win over the Wallabies, Townsend leapt to the defence of his star man once again.

‘I thought he was excellent, I really did,’ said Townsend. ‘I felt he was our leader tactically in terms of the decisions to make. And it’s a tough game for a 10 when you’re not able to maybe play with as much width in your game. And you’re looking at tight options but the defence are closing that down.

Russell tackles Australia’s Max Jorgensen as his defensive skills were tested

‘I thought he had a couple of excellent kicks in behind. And I thought he was really dialled in in terms of what the team needed. And sometimes in our game, he doesn’t get to kick a lot.’

Pressed on whether too much is expected of Russell in terms of being brilliant in every single game, Townsend continued: ‘I suppose that’s for you guys to decide. I think he’s very much appreciated by us and I hope by you guys as well. And also the supporters. Yeah, he’s a team player. He’s delighted the team beat Australia and he played his part in that.’

Russell remains the country’s best and most influential player, although the loss of captain Sione Tuipulotu in midfield against the Aussies was undoubtedly a major blow to the attack.

Australia were hugely disappointing against Scotland and the talk from Townsend about it being ‘the best defensive performance in the last couple of years’ should be tempered.

That was just a way to try and take some of the heat off defence coach Lee Radford. The reality is that Australia didn’t really fire many meaningful shots at all in attack.

But neither did Scotland. And that’s the big concern. That sense of magic around Russell, the feeling that Scotland can score tries from anywhere on the field, has been conspicuous by its absence.

Given that Townsend will almost certainly make a load of changes for the game against Japan on Saturday, it feels unlikely that Russell will play.

Exploring other options at fly-half is necessary. Russell is 34 years old now and isn’t going to be around forever.

Then again, perhaps it would be wise to try and let him play his way back into some form, given that Scotland should win with plenty to spare against a Japan side who shipped 78 points against England at Twickenham last weekend.

Either way, Scotland need the real Finn Russell to stand up heading into the finals weekend of this Nations Championship.



Source link

Share.
Exit mobile version