Close Menu

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest headlines from PapaLinc about news & entertainment.

    What's Hot

    Bawumia meets film industry stakeholders; calls for tax incentives, streaming platform

    How data centres are turning AI-generated heat into energy | News

    Investigation launched into Julio Iglesias after two former employees alleged sexual abuse

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    • Lifestyle
    • Africa News
    • International
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube WhatsApp
    PapaLincPapaLinc
    • News
      • Africa News
      • International
    • Entertainment
      • Lifestyle
      • Movies
      • Music
    • Politics
    • Sports
    Subscribe
    PapaLincPapaLinc
    You are at:Home»News»International»Ex Green minister Patrick Harvie under fire for plan to set up buffer zones for assisted dying clinics
    International

    Ex Green minister Patrick Harvie under fire for plan to set up buffer zones for assisted dying clinics

    Papa LincBy Papa LincOctober 28, 2025No Comments4 Mins Read3 Views
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest Telegram LinkedIn Tumblr Email Reddit
    Ex Green minister Patrick Harvie under fire for plan to set up buffer zones for assisted dying clinics
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest WhatsApp Email


    By TOM GORDON, DEPUTY SCOTTISH POLITICAL EDITOR

    Published: 17:33 EDT, 28 October 2025 | Updated: 17:33 EDT, 28 October 2025

    Former Scottish Green minister Patrick Harvie has come under fire for ‘totalitarian’ plans to set up abortion clinic-style buffer zones around places used for assisted suicide.

    The Glasgow MSP has tabled an amendment to the Assisted Dying Bill at Holyrood to give ministers the power to create ‘safe access zones’.

    If passed, the legislation would make it a criminal offence for someone to impede, harass, alarm, distress or influence the decision of a person ending their own life.

    But with many assisted suicides overseas done at home, critics said the measure could criminalise family members and create ‘censorship zones’ across Scotland.

    Gordon Macdonald, chief executive of Care Not Killing called it draconian and dangerous.

    Even the MSP behind the Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults Bill said he was ‘sceptical’.

    MSPs approved the general principles of the Bill by 70 to 56 in a free vote in May.

    Proposed by Orkney Liberal Democrat Liam McArthur, it would give terminally ill adults the right to ask for a self-taken lethal drug if overseen by two doctors.

    Mr Harvie’s amendment is to due to be debated when the Bill returns to parliament next month for line-by-line consideration in committee.

    Ex Green minister Patrick Harvie under fire for plan to set up buffer zones for assisted dying clinics

    Former Scottish Green party co-leader Patrick Harvey

    His idea echoes the protest-free buffer zones created by fellow Green MSP Gillian Mackay through her Abortion Services (Safe Access Zones) Act last year.

    That law specified a 200m exclusion zone around hospitals and clinics.

    Mr Harvie’s amendment would empower ministers to ‘establish safe access zones’ for premises used for assisted dying, but leave them to fill in the details.

    Gordon Macdonald, chief executive of Care Not Killing, which opposes the Assisted Dying legislation, warned the plan could ‘create censorship zones in large parts of the country’.

    He cited the experience of the US state of Oregon, where 80 per cent of assisted suicides occur at home and added: ‘We could see, in theory, buffer zones of 200m round the homes of the vast majority of patients.

    ‘Family members, doctors, priests, nurses or anyone else who in any way seeks to influence the patient not to commit suicide risks being criminalised.

    ‘Priests might be banned from giving the last rites or a church nearby might be banned from holding a public meeting on the subject of assisted suicide.

    ‘A GP surgery near a care home might have to take down the Samaritans poster from the notice board in the waiting room. It could ban a family member from crying.

    ‘Yet there has been no evidence of harassment of people applying for assisted suicide or euthanasia anywhere in the world.

    ‘Patrick Harvie reveals his true colours with such a Draconian, dangerous, selfish, unnecessary and totalitarian proposal.’

    Mr McArthur said: ‘I welcome the fact that colleagues have lodged their own amendments aimed at strengthening and improving the Bill.

    ‘In relation to the amendment on “safe access zones”, I am not aware of these operating in other jurisdictions.

    ‘As it’s likely that people who choose to have an assisted death may do so at home and not necessarily in a specific hospital setting, it is difficult to see how this would replicate what we’ve seen with abortion clinics.

    ‘I will listen to what Patrick has to say but I am sceptical of the need for such a provision in this Bill.’

    Mr Harvie said: ‘My amendment will allow Parliament to discuss whether measures might be needed in future to protect people from harassment and intimidation by the same kind of American-funded groups who have targeted abortion clinics across Scotland. I’ll see how the discussion goes before deciding whether to press this to a vote.

    ‘It is important that if this bill is passed, safeguards are in place to protect those workers providing the service as well as patients.’

    Share or comment on this article:
    Ex Green minister Patrick Harvie under fire for plan to set up buffer zones for assisted dying clinics



    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp Telegram Email
    Previous ArticleInvest in Health Workers Training and Retention — Merck Foundation Board Chair
    Next Article Actress Jemima Osunde bags a master’s degree in public health from the University of Suffolk (VIDEO)
    Papa Linc

    Related Posts

    Investigation launched into Julio Iglesias after two former employees alleged sexual abuse

    November 18, 2026

    High-flying businessman who says he was struck down with chronic fatigue after taking hepatitis B vaccine sues NHS for more than £1m

    November 18, 2026

    How plan to tackle youth unemployment would require a ‘whole system reset’ and will cost the UK billions

    November 18, 2026
    Ads
    Top Posts

    ‘Psychological torture’: Clients of suspended lawyer Michael Inger claim they were strung along for years – until a woman living in ‘agony’ received a devastating email from the Personal Injury Commission

    October 12, 2026197 Views

    Newsreader Sandy Gall personally lobbied Margaret Thatcher’s government to back the Mujahideen

    July 4, 2025182 Views

    Secret code break that ‘solved’ the Zodiac killer case: Expert who unmasked single suspect behind two of America’s darkest murders tells all on bombshell investigation

    December 24, 2025162 Views

    Tech entrepreneur uses ChatGPT to create a personalised cancer vaccine for his DOG – and the breakthrough could soon help humans too

    March 14, 2026154 Views
    Don't Miss
    News November 18, 2026

    Bawumia meets film industry stakeholders; calls for tax incentives, streaming platform

    Former Vice-President and New Patriotic Party (NPP) flag bearer Dr Mahamudu Bawumia has called for…

    How data centres are turning AI-generated heat into energy | News

    Investigation launched into Julio Iglesias after two former employees alleged sexual abuse

    Ghana, US deepen cooperation to tackle mercury pollution

    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • WhatsApp

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest headlines from PapaLinc about news & entertainment.

    Ads
    About Us
    About Us

    Your authentic source for news and entertainment.
    We're accepting new partnerships right now.

    Email Us: info@papalinc.com
    For Ads on our website and social handles.
    Email Us: ads@papalinc.com
    Contact: +1-718-924-6727

    Facebook X (Twitter) Pinterest YouTube WhatsApp
    Our Picks

    Bawumia meets film industry stakeholders; calls for tax incentives, streaming platform

    How data centres are turning AI-generated heat into energy | News

    Investigation launched into Julio Iglesias after two former employees alleged sexual abuse

    Most Popular

    “We Nigerians love you people, don’t be a client” – Tiktoker Peller tells UK young boy (VIDEO)

    December 20, 20240 Views

    Pharmacist told patient her son’s autism was caused by MMR jab and recommended he ‘detox’ by taking ‘vitamins’

    February 11, 20250 Views

    Corby releases emotive new single “Wide Awake”

    March 28, 20250 Views
    © 2026 PapaLinc. Designed by LiveTechOn LLC.
    • News
      • Africa News
      • International
    • Entertainment
      • Lifestyle
      • Movies
      • Music
    • Politics
    • Sports

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Ad Blocker Enabled!
    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.