Two stunning new pieces of evidence have been revealed after Colorado husband Barry Morphew was indicted for the murder of his wife Suzanne.
Suzanne, 43, vanished from the couple’s stunning $1.5 million home in Marysville, 150 miles from Denver, in May 2020, with Barry, 53, charged on Friday.
Barry Morphew was arrested in Arizona earlier today and has been charged with first-degree murder. The landscaper’s bail was set at $3 million, with investigators set to hold a press conference at 6pm MT with further details about the case.
And an indictment seen by DailyMail.com revealed that Suzanne died with the presence of a powerful animal tranquilizer called butorphanol-azaperone-medetomidine (BAM) in her body.
The charging document released Friday delivered an apparent smoking gun in theatrical style.
‘Ultimately, the prescription records show that when Suzanne Morphew disappeared, only one private citizen living in that entire area of the state had access to BAM: Barry Morphew,’ it said.
A tranquilizer needle cap, darts and a tranquillizer gun were found in the couple’s home during a law enforcement search conducted shortly after Suzanne vanished.
Barry used BAM to hunt deer while in the couple’s native Indiana. They moved to Colorado from the Hoosier State in 2018 and were having severe marital difficulties at the time of Suzanne’s disappearance.
The much-loved mom vanished while the younger of the couple’s two daughter’s Macy was away from the family home for a few days. Cops allege Barry killed Suzanne on the morning of May 9 2020, the day before her disappearance was reported.
Suzanne Morphew was reported missing on May 10, 2020. Her husband Barry Morphew has been charged with first-degree murder
Barry denied all knowledge of the killing – but was quickly named the prime suspect and charged with Suzanne’s murder
Barry was first charged with murdering his wife in 2021, in the absence of his wife’s body.
But the case collapsed amid prosecutorial misconduct, with Macy and the couple’s other daughter Mallory both standing by their father throughout.
A new team of prosecutors began probing Barry again after Suzanne’s body was discovered dumped along the side of a rural road in Saguache County, Colorado in September 2023 in a patch of wasteland known as ‘The Boneyard.’
That is about an hour’s drive south of the Morphew residence.
And more dramatic evidence revealed for the first time Friday revealed that Suzanne did not die where her body was found.
Forensic experts said the lack of animal activity on Suzanne’s body combined with the lack of decomposure of the cycling clothes she was wearing mean ‘it was unlikely Suzanne decomposed from a fresh body to a skeleton at this location.’
The charging document did not offer any further theories or evidence as to where investigators believe Suzanne was killed or where her body was initially concealed.
No cause of death has been given because of how badly Suzanne had decomposed, but a coroner’s report said she’d died with the BAM tranquilizer in her system.
Their daughters Mallory and Macy stuck by Barry throughout the initial charges brought against him and pushed back against claims that he killed their mother
Suzanne was reported missing by her neighbor on Mother’s Day 2020 after Mallory and Macy were unable to reach her on the phone.
Her last communication with a friend was on May 9, the day investigators believe Barry killed her.
Barry and Suzanne were alone at their home at the time of the disappearance.
On May 6, Suzanne texted Barry saying: ‘I’m done. I could (sic) care less what you’re up to and have been for years. We just need to figure this out civilly.’
Barry claimed he left home early on the morning of May 10 to go to work in the Colorado city of Broomfield, three hours from their home.
He said that Suzanne was asleep in their bed, having told him she was planning a bike ride for her day.
Investigators insist Suzanne had already been dead for hours at that point.
Barry’s phone entered and exited airplane mode several times over the next 24 hours, authorities said.
The door of his truck was opened numerous times between 3.25am and 5am and was backed up into the home’s garage at least once.
Further arousing suspicion was Barry’s activity in Broomfield.
He claimed to have been on a landscaping job but spent a total of just 90 minutes on site and the rest in a cheap hotel room that cleaners reported stank of chlorine after he checked out.
Barry was captured on surveillance making several trash runs at numerous locations around town, but appeared to be doing little work, police noted.
Suzanne’s disappearance was reported to police on the evening of May 10 – Mothering Sunday – after Macy and Mallory said they had been unable to contact their mother.
Barry asked a neighbor to check on the house and then asked them to call the sheriff when the neighbor saw no trace of Suzanne.
During a subsequent police interview, Barry claimed the couple’s marriage was ‘the best’ and that they’d just had a ‘wonderful weekend together.’
But that was a lie; Suzanne had been having a two year affair with an old school friend called Jeff Libler and despised her husband, it is alleged.
After cops began to search the property, they found Suzanne’s bike abandoned down a steep embankment close to the family home.
Police believe that scene was staged.
Her helmet was discovered days later, roughly a mile away, at the side of a highway.
The disappearance of an attractive, wealthy mother soon sparked a nationwide media frenzy.
A tearful Barry even released a brief video appeal to the public asking for information.
‘Suzanne, if anyone is out there that can hear this that has you, please, we’ll do whatever it takes to bring you back,’ Barry said.
Meanwhile, a huge manhunt was launched, with authorities scouring rural terrain, diving in lakes, and deploying K9 units to find Suzanne – but there was no trace.
Barry and Suzanne Morphew are pictured with daughters Macy and Mallory
When Barry was questioned by police two days after Suzanne disappeared, officers noted he had scratches on his hands and arms.
A search of the Morphew home found a live .22 caliber bullet by Suzanne’s bed, and a needle cap from a tranquilizer dart was found in the dryer, tangled up among washed bed sheets.
Investigators also recovered empty tranquilizer darts, a needle used to inject tranquilizer chemicals into the darts, and a dart gun.
Barry Morphew admitted to using a tranquilizer gun to shoot deer so he could harvest their horns, but said he was unsure how the cap got in the dryer, court records show.
Barry made a series of trash dumps in Broomfield on the day Suzanne was reported missing
Suzanne Morphew’s remains were found in the fall of 2023. Cadaver dogs are pictured at the scene where Chaffee County Sheriff’s officers, FBI and CBI were searching in Colorado
Barry Morphew will now be extradited to the San Luis Valley in Colorado to face charges.
His daughters have yet to comment on the charges brought against their father.
Suzanne’s loved ones including her sister Melinda had previously condemned Barry over his alleged treatment of his wife and claimed Suzanne had feared for her safety.
‘Federal, State and local law enforcement have never stopped working toward justice for Suzanne,’ Twelfth Judicial District Attorney Anne Kelly said Friday.
‘The Twelfth Judicial District Attorney’s Office stands in solidarity with Suzanne’s family and the citizens of Chaffee and Saguache Counties in pursuing the Grand Jury’s indictment.’
