RTÉ’s Head of Sport said he would not have hired former Newstalk presenter Gery Gilroy to host the station’s new sports podcast if it was his decision, the Mail has learned.
Declan McBennett made the admission at a heated meeting of RTÉ sports staff and members of the Montrose management team, including Director General Kevin Bakhurst, on Wednesday.
Sources who attended the meeting said Mr Bakhurst began and ended the packed room by warning those present that they should not talk to the media or politicians about what was happening in the department.
It comes after the National Union of Journalists (NUJ) sports chapel [branch] passed a unanimous motion of no-confidence in the RTÉ leadership team last week.
They were reacting to the ‘embarrassment, dishonour and ridicule, brought to RTÉ yet again’, by the appointment of Mr Gilroy as presenter of the station’s flagship sports podcast, Howler.
RTÉ has denied that Mr Gilroy is being paid €190,000 plus allowances for the role.
However, Mr Gilroy is believed to have been catapulted straight into the list of RTÉ’s top earners after his former colleague at Newstalk, Hugh Ormond – now RTÉ’s Head of Podcasts – contacted him earlier this year with the idea of a daily sports podcast.
It emerged at a recent meeting of the Oireachtas Media Committee that Mr McBennett was only informed about Mr Gilroy’s appointment four days before it was announced.
RTÉ has denied that Ger Gilroy is being paid €190,000 plus allowances for the role
One attendee at this week’s meeting, which took place in the sports department at the Donnybrook campus and lasted over an hour, told the MoS: ‘Declan was pressed and pressed in the meeting, and eventually he was asked whether he would have hired Gilroy, and he said no. That tells you everything.’
The meeting also heard repeated concerns from RTÉ sports personnel about the fact that female sports have hardly featured in Mr Gilroy’s new podcast, which began broadcasting last month.
Deputy Director General Adrian Lynch said management wanted to draw in an 18- to 35-year-old male audience.
One source close to the department told the MoS: ‘This reply absolutely incensed me. Is the podcast catering for the manosphere? The older men in RTÉ’s management seem to think that young men aren’t interested in women’s sport. The very opposite is true. These people, all of them, are dinosaurs.’
Mr Bakhurst assured staff he was also ‘concerned’ about the lack of female sports stars in the Howler podcast to date.
The MoS understands that sports department employees also asked Mr Bakhurst where internal applicants had fallen down in their applications to host the podcast after the expression of interest in the podcast was opened to staff members earlier this year.
Mr Bakhurst assured staff he was also ‘concerned’ about the lack of female sports stars in the Howler podcast to date
Specifically, they asked how they could improve on subsequent applications for future jobs.
Mr Bakhurst reportedly replied that the first key ingredient in any application was to provide a showreel (a recording showcasing a person’s previous work). Asked if Mr Gilroy had provided a showreel, the management team said they didn’t know, according to sources.
Last week, the MoS confirmed that sports presenters Jacqui Hurley, Darragh Moloney, Paul O’Flynn, Claire McNamara and Eamon Horan were among 60 staff who attended a meeting the previous Wednesday, from which the damning statement professing no faith in Mr Bakhurst and his team was issued.
The same people were present at this week’s meeting.
The statement said the current RTÉ executive was appointed to bring about a new culture where decisions would be made ‘transparently’ and to promote a culture ‘where every voice is valued and collaboration thrives’.
‘It has manifestly failed to do so,’ the statement said.
Declan McBennett made the admission at a heated meeting of RTÉ sports staff and members of the Montrose management team, including Director General Kevin Bakhurst on Wednesday
This followed the appearance of RTÉ senior leadership at the Oireachtas Media Committee on November 4, where a hoarse Mr Bakhurst, Mr Lynch and Head of Audio Patricia Monahan attempted to explain and defend the circumstances surrounding the appointment of Mr Gilroy to the new sports podcast.
Ms Monahan was previously quoted by the Irish Independent as saying that Mr Gilroy applied via an expressions-of-interest process.
At the media committee, she insisted that she ‘never said that Ger applied through an expression-of-interest process’ but had taken part in one, after which he was deemed ‘the most appropriate candidate’.
At the committee meeting, chairman Alan Kelly suggested this was effectively ‘head-hunting’ and was being viewed as the latest in a reverse Newstalk takeover of RTÉ.
In an interview with the Irish Times ahead of the committee meeting, Mr Gilroy confirmed that he received a call from Hugh Ormond, who pitched the daily sports podcast to him.
He also said his podcast was aimed at men, adding that a ‘female-targeted product’ will be launched in the new year.
At Wednesday’s meeting, Mr Bakhurst and Mr Lynch were joined by Steve Carson, the Director of Video at RTÉ.
One attendee at this week’s meeting, which took place in the sports department at the Donnybrook campus and lasted over an hour, told the MoS: ‘Declan was pressed and pressed in the meeting, and eventually he was asked whether he would have hired Gilroy, and he said no. That tells you everything’
In a statement later, a spokesperson said the broadcaster’s leadership team ‘looks forward to ongoing engagement with colleagues in RTÉ Sport and to working through any outstanding issues as we continue to deliver RTÉ’s New Direction strategy’.
The statement, which was broadcast on RTÉ’s news channels, also said it had been a ‘constructive meeting with colleagues in RTÉ Sport’.
However, a senior RTÉ sports presenter who attended the meeting said they were baffled by this description.
‘I don’t know what meeting they were at but that wasn’t the feeling at the meeting I was at,’ they said. ‘People were very fed up. This is a mess entirely of RTÉ management’s own making.
‘On management’s side, there is a real sense that they want this dealt with and forgotten by the time their next appearance in front of PAC [Public Accounts Committee] comes around.’
Contacted by the MoS this weekend on his assertion that he would not have hired Mr Gilroy, Mr McBennett declined to comment.
In response to queries from the MoS, an RTÉ spokeswoman said: ‘While details within your questioning are factually incorrect, RTÉ does not wish to provide details of an internal meeting between the Director General, Deputy Director General, Head of RTÉ Sport and the RTÉ Sport department.’
She did not clarify what aspects of our queries were ‘factually incorrect’.

