An oil painting that hung ‘inconspicuously’ in a back hallway for 25 years has sold for £350,000, causing a shock to its owner after selling at 500 times its estimated value.
The owner inherited the 17th century painting called ‘Portrait of a Lady in fur trimmed coat and hat’ from a Scottish relative.
She believes it had been in the family for more than a century and survived being sold off to cover her great-grandfather’s gambling debts because it was not thought to be as valuable as other treasures.
Not realising its value, she hung it above a door in the back hall of her home in Suffolk for years.
She decided to sell it at Colchester-based Reeman Dansie ahead of a house move.
They gave it a pre-sale estimate of between £500 and £700.
But the market decided the unsigned painting was the work of a mystery Old Master who was a close follower of Rembrandt.
It triggered a 25-minute bidding war which ended with the hammer dropping on £350,000, meaning it sold at 500 times the estimate.
Jonathan Benson, of Reeman Dansie, alongside the painting which sold at 500 times its estimated value
With fees added on the London-based buyer paid a staggering £437,500 for the rare artwork.
The seller, who did not want to be identified, was delighted with the result, which will make retirement more comfortable.
Jonathan Benson, of Reeman Dansie, said he rang the client afterwards and told her it had done ‘quite well’.
She asked: ‘Well enough for us to turn left or right on the aeroplane?’
Mr Benson replied: ‘You might even decide to buy an aeroplane.’
He continued: ‘She was absolutely thrilled, it’s no small figure and will make retirement rather more comfortable.
‘She called me back later and said she’d found it difficult to concentrate on her bridge game she was playing.’
Experts have speculated the painting is the work of a Dutch painter who is known only as Monogrammist IS or Master IS, due to the signature found on some of his other works.
Other specialists have suggested it could be a lost original, after a similar version on canvas emerged in 2010 that was attributed to the artist.
The Suffolk-based client came from a Scottish family and inherited the artwork around 25 years ago.
They believe the painting may have been in the family since the turn of the century.
The client’s great-grandfather gambled away various family fortunes, but this perhaps wasn’t deemed as saleable as some of the other things, Mr Benson said.
He said: ‘When she inherited it, it was just described as an oil on panel portrait of a lady. It hung in a back hall, above a door, very inconspicuous and out of the limelight for the last 25 years.’
Mr Benson has sold a number of items for the client ahead of a move and suggested seeing how much they could get for the piece.
The owner inherited the 17th century painting called ‘Portrait of a Lady in fur trimmed coat and hat’ from a Scottish relative
He added: ‘It was a great surprise. Never in my wildest dream did I think it would fetch that sort of sum. I thought surely it’s going to stop in a moment. Before we knew it, it was at £150,000, then £200,000.
‘With these old masterpieces, it is very feast or famine. Everyone is an expert after the event.
‘We had international interest but eventually it sold to a London buyer, who I imagine knows more than we do. It’s a wonderful great punt.
‘It’s beautifully painted but it’s quite a niche thing. This Monogrammist IS, only a handful of works have appeared at auction.
‘I think the fact he hasn’t even got a name adds to the intrigue of it all.

